constitutional conventions
-
An Originalism for North Freedonia
Thoughts on an essay on “Originalism without Text” by Stephen Sachs ― and its relevance to Canada Continue reading
-
Judicial Independence in America
A look at the conventions of judicial independence in the United States Continue reading
-
The Court on Conventions
Shameless self-promotion for my latest academic article Continue reading
-
Too Conventional
The UK Supreme Court’s conventional, and indefensible, thinking on the issue of constitutional conventions Continue reading
-
Unconstitutional
Thoughts on the constitutionality of the new Supreme Court appointments process In my last post, I argued that the process for appointing Supreme Court judges announced by the federal government last week is not a positive development. It will neither increase the transparency of the appointments nor de-politicize them, while creating an illusion of having done Continue reading
-
(Un)conventional
No, constitutional conventions cannot stop free trade within Canada I didn’t write about the “Free the Beer” decision, R. v. Comeau, 2016 NBPC 3, when it came out this spring. It took me a very long time to read, and others beat me to it ― notably Benjamin Oliphant, to whose excellent analysis over at Policy Continue reading
-
(Still) a Convention?
At his History News blog, Christopher Moore is arguing that “responsible government is not a ‘convention’.” In his view, the “basis of responsible government in Canada” is right there in the constitutional text ― specifically, in the provisions of the Constitution Act, 1867 that deal with money votes. Dale Smith replies in a post at Continue reading
-
De la formation du gouvernement
Juste avant les élections fédérales en Octobre, j’avais participé (en compagnie de Hoi Kong) à une mini-conférence à l’Université de Montréal, intitulée « Gouvernements minoritaires et/ou de coalition : Legality and/or Legitimacy ». La chose m’avait échappé à l’époque, mais ma présentation est disponible en ligne. Évidemment, elle ne s’est pas avérée très pertinente vu Continue reading
-
Let’s Hear It
I’ve mentioned Aniz Alani’s challenge to the constitutionality of the Prime Minister’s apparent and admitted policy of not making any Senate appointments before. The federal government moved to strike Mr. Alani’s application for judicial review, arguing that it had no chance of success, and also that the Federal Court had no jurisdiction to hear it. Yesterday, that Continue reading
-
All or Nothing
I want to come back, briefly, to the crazy idea I put forward last weekend, about the Governor General starting to appoint Senators without waiting for Prime Ministerial advice if it becomes clear that such advice is not and will not be forthcoming. Actually, maybe it wasn’t such a crazy idea because, as Aniz Alani Continue reading
Double Aspect 